rental real estate strategy & past relfection

I wrote the first half of this post in 2020, laying out my rental strategy for the next few years. Rebuilding this blog in 2026, I figured the most useful thing I could do was grade my own plan. Here’s what I thought would happen, and what actually did.

The 2020 Plan

I spent time writing out and thinking through my rental business strategy. I’d figured out a rental model that works in an expensive market while working full time.

Each mortgage payment was growing my equity by about $600 per property. My little real estate business was chugging along.

The plan:

  1. Build equity in my Northern Colorado properties until each hit a 78% loan-to-value.
  2. Cash-out refinance and put that money into more cash-flowing real estate, while keeping each property cash flowing $200 to $500 a month after expenses.
  3. Nomad house hack my way to properties 4, 5, 6, and 7 over the next 4 years, renting each one out room by room.
  4. Reach level 1 financial freedom: about $2,000 a month in true cash flow, enough to cover my bills with free housing, no personal bad debt, and some savings once my SUV and student loans were paid off.

I was sticking to what I knew: house hacking and self-management.

My goal at 27 was financial independence by 34 through real estate. By then, I expected close to $1M in equity, plus a solid paper asset portfolio compounding in the background for old age, while I lived on rental cash flow.

It lined up with a piece of common wisdom: “Hustle in your 20s, build in your 30s.”

My 20s were all about hustling: learning, growing a career I saw a future in (digital marketing and sales), networking, and taking big risks (two rentals). Entering my 30s, the focus would shift to building: business systems with strong rental cash flow, a location-independent online business, and a steadily growing paper asset nest egg.


Where I Actually Am in 2026

I’m 36 now. Here’s the honest scorecard.

Nomad properties 4 through 7: Didn’t happen

I stopped at three properties. I don’t have plans to buy more rentals. Instead, my strategy shifted toward building my stock portfolio, mainly broad U.S. and international index funds in a taxable brokerage account.

Why? A few reasons. Prices and rates went up a lot after 2020, which made new deals much harder to pencil out. Self-managing three properties turned out to be plenty. And I learned that stocks give me something rentals don’t: growth with zero tenant phone calls.

The cash-out refinance: Didn’t happen, and I’m glad

All three properties have fixed-rate mortgages under 4%. When rates jumped, a cash-out refi would have meant trading cheap debt for expensive debt. Holding those low-rate loans turned out to be one of the best financial decisions I never had to make. Sometimes the best move is no move.

Self-management: A hard lesson

In 2020, I was worried about tenants not getting along. The reality was worse. I let bad tenants take over one of my properties, and they did a lot of damage. It was hard, scary, and expensive. I got through it, signed a 12-month lease with a great family, and the property still cash flows. But it taught me that self-management is only as good as your screening, and that reserves aren’t optional.

Full-time job: Gone

The 2020 plan assumed a steady W-2 job would fund everything. The W-2 path didn’t last. I’ve now been self-employed for over a year, running my own performance marketing business. I lost the steady paycheck the plan depended on, but the rentals and the portfolio are a big part of why I could afford to bet on myself.

Financial independence by 34: Partially

I didn’t hit the exact plan, but I got somewhere I’m proud of. My invested portfolio, rental equity plus stocks, crossed seven figures. I’m Coast FI: if I never invested another dollar, compounding should still carry me to a comfortable retirement. My rental cash flow covers a baseline floor, and my brokerage account is the growth engine.

What I didn’t account for in 2020: my lifestyle grew. $2,000 a month was my “level 1” number back then. My actual life today costs more than that. That’s not a failure. It means my definition of “enough” grew with my life, and my new target is a higher, more realistic monthly number from rentals and dividends combined.

The online business: In progress

Still building. My current goal is an online business that pays me at least $10,000 a month, so I never have to go back to a W-2 job.

What I Got Right

  • House hacking early. It was the single best decision of my 20s. It got me into three properties without inherited money.
  • Locking in cheap, fixed-rate debt. Those sub-4% mortgages are gold.
  • Building a paper asset portfolio alongside real estate. It ended up becoming the main engine.
  • “Hustle in your 20s, build in your 30s.” Still true.

What I Got Wrong

  • Assuming the job would always be there. Never build a plan that depends on one employer.
  • Underestimating management risk. One bad tenant can wipe out years of cash flow from that property.
  • Planning like the market would stay the same. 2020 rates and prices were a moment, not a forever.
  • Setting my “enough” number too low. Plan for the life you’ll want at 35, not the one you can tolerate at 27.

The Updated Strategy

  1. Hold the three rentals, keep the cheap debt, and let tenants keep paying them down. They should be paid off by my mid-50s.
  2. Keep bigger reserves than I used to think I needed.
  3. Put new money into index funds, U.S. and international, as the main growth engine.
  4. Grow the business to the point where my income is fully in my own hands.

Back in 2020, I predicted my thinking would look very different in 5 years. It does. The plan changed. The mission didn’t.

Make the plan, work the plan, then be honest enough to grade it.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *